Among your large collection of vinyls there can be only 1 playing at a time (unless you got a crazy setup). Almost every digital media displays what is playing at the moment, and you want something similar for you analog media. The solution is to print this project in you favorite color. If you do have a crazy setup, you could consider printing 2.

The idea is to print the front and back, and glue them together.

Have fun and I hope you will enjoy it.