My toaster handle kept slipping out and eventually snapped in half.  I designed this one so you can actually secure it to the lowering assembly and reassemble the whole contraption.  

NOTE: Be careful not to bend the metal tabs on the outer housing and also remove the dial before attempting to reattach both ends of the toaster to the metal housing.

Print as-is, where-is, without support.

If you found this useful, it would bring me great joy to see your work - so be sure to share. :)

Or, better yet, please feel free to dump a bitcoin or two here:

1Py3TUeR8noBN2giHyFV1GfB6x3Kh2WEVv

... include a note to the effect of "Hi Julius3E8, thanks for the toaster oven handle thing... my life has improved five-fold on account of it and please accept this paltry amount in gratitude".

You're welcome! (in advance) :D

Also, feel free to peruse my other submissions which are almost as varied as they are many:

https://www.printables.com/social/320993-julius3e8/models

http://www.thingiverse.com/Julius3E8/designs

Enjoy!